| Rank | Top 10 Christmas Cookies |
| 1 | Jeweled Coconut Drops |
| 2 | Gingerbread Men Cookies |
| 3 | Peppermint Meltaways |
| 4 | Buttery Spritz Cookies |
| 5 | Whipped Shortbread |
| 6 | Rum Balls |
| 7 | Cranberry-White Chocolate Cookies |
| 8 | Scottish Shortbread |
| 9 | Double Whammy Eggnog Cookies |
| 10 | Vanilla-Butter Sugar Cookies |
